I agree with you, I don’t mind the concept of a third brother either, but only if it was next season or some further down the road season (I know they’re only supposed to do 5 but a girl can dream). Once Dean and Sam deal with the whole angels vs. demons, brothers on the opposite sides thing that they’re setting up, then maybe they can deal with a long lost sibling. It might bring them closer together in a following season for example. But they certainly don’t need it right now.

And yeah, the casting thing is what worries me the most. Now they have had some hits lately, with Castiel and Mary and Grandpa Sam but they’ve had some major misses (Hello Ruby!) as well. So I will be very frightened waiting to see if someone is cast and if they do bear some resemblance to all 3 Winchesters. I agree, impossible. Plus the chemistry between JA and JP…I just don’t want that messed with. Unless he was a one shot character and they went their separate ways and/or he died. I don’t see the point of that though, so it does indeed worry me.

Hopefully this is just a Kripke foiler to try to keep the fans guessing and maybe to sneak in something we don’t like, but we won’t mind as much as we would a third brother. I do know that he hits the net so I’m hoping he’ll see someone’s response (I’m not egotistical enough to think it would be mine!) and stops the idea in its tracks or at least puts it off til next season though.

I actually wouldn’t mind a third Pretty on the show since Daddy Winchester disappeared, but there’s a catch or two.

1. Bringing a third brother this season or the next is way too soon. As you said, there’s more than enough issues and conflicts between Dean and Sam with them possibly fighting each other while angels and demons watch. The epic battle.

They really should have the guts to play this to the end, hit all the beats, but they don’t. and that’s the greatest sin of all shows and all writers these days. I really shouldn’t bother but after finishing watching another show that disappointed me, I’d weep if SN did disappoint me like that. And they just might.

2. They would need a stellar casting. They would need someone who remotely looks like JDM and JA and JP with pretty hints from another woman. That is a next to an impossible task and after seeing what the casting of this show has done with the female characters (possibly excluding Mary and the blind seer), I don’t trust them one bit.

I can’t lay claim to foiler, I think it came from TWoP, but it is an awesome word!

Did you see the new one from Ausello this morning?
apparently there’s a traitor among them! I sure hope it’s Bella and we can get rid of Genny for good. I like Bella, dislike the actress with a passion.

SUPERNATURAL ROCKS

It’s helped me discovered that I’m really gay and have manlove for both Dean and Sam. I have given up that crappy OTH show and given my heart, and other parts, to SN.

Got it? Be useful or be gone.

One Tree Hill is way better